Symphony No. 1 in A-flat major

Edward Elgar

Sir John Barbirolli / Philharmonia Orchestra

1962 Very good stereo sound.

Top choice. Barbirolli brings 'passion, commitment, sensitivity, and humanity' that sells the work. Noted for the gorgeous string sound, especially the melody over harp arpeggios in the finale.

Sir Edward Elgar / London Symphony Orchestra

1930 Historical recording. Sound is 'not bad' for its time.

Elgar's own 'dramatic, exciting, committed performance.' You get the composer's authority combined with a 'spontaneity and the sense of discovery'.